Tottenville High School: average SAT score, 2017-2024
#66 of 548 citywide · 1026/1600 in 2024 · Staten Island · DBN 31R455
- SAT total, 2024
- 1026
- Math
- 509
- Reading & writing
- 517
- Students counted
- 779
In 2024, students at Tottenville High School who sat the SAT averaged 1026 out of 1600 — 509 on Math and 517 on Reading and Writing. That is 47 points above the 979 averaged across the 461 New York City high schools that reported a score that year. Within Staten Island it sits essentially on the borough average of 1023. Citywide it ranks 66 of 548. In Staten Island it is 3 of 15.
Across 8 measured years, the school's average went from 1087 in 2017 to 1026 in 2024, down 61 points. The peak was 1088 in 2018 and the floor 1011 in 2023, a spread of 77 points. Citywide the average moved down 37 points over the same span, so relative to the rest of New York this school is behind by 24 points.
The sharpest single move came between 2019 and 2020, when the average dropped 54 points in one year. That is the pandemic cohort, and it moved almost everywhere in the city, so it says more about the year than about the school. Its place in the citywide order has hardly changed: 55 of 453 in 2017, 61 of 461 in 2024.
The 2024 figure is the average of 779 students at this school who actually sat the exam — not of the whole graduating class. Of those test takers, 34% on Math and 53% on Reading and Writing cleared the College Board's college-readiness benchmark. The two sections are far apart here: Reading and Writing clears the bar for a much larger share of students than Math does, which is usually where a prep plan starts.
The highest average in Staten Island that year belonged to Staten Island Technical High School, at 1436, 410 points ahead of Tottenville High School. A gap that size is a different admissions pool, not a different amount of preparation.
Eight years against the city
SAT total out of 1600. The dashed line is the citywide average for the same years, weighted by the number of students counted at each school.
Year by year
| Year | SAT total | Math | Reading & writing | Tested | College ready, math | College ready, R&W |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | 1087 | 544 | 543 | 933 | 53% | 71% |
| 2018 | 1088 | 545 | 543 | 831 | 51% | 69% |
| 2019 | 1067 | 532 | 535 | 892 | 50% | 70% |
| 2020 | 1013 | 509 | 504 | 812 | 37% | 49% |
| 2021 | 1053 | 526 | 527 | 651 | 34% | 51% |
| 2022 | 1020 | 508 | 512 | 775 | 34% | 51% |
| 2023 | 1011 | 500 | 511 | 849 | 33% | 51% |
| 2024 | 1026 | 509 | 517 | 779 | 34% | 53% |
| City, 2024 | 979 | 487 | 492 | 53,619 | — | — |
| Staten Island, 2024 | 1023 | 508 | 515 | 3,526 | — | — |
“Tested” is the number of students the DOE counted in that year’s average, not the size of the class. “College ready” is the share of those students who met the College Board benchmark on that section. A dash means the DOE published no figure for that year; nothing here is estimated.
Next
- Compare all 549 New York City high schools on the same figures, sortable by borough and by score.
- SAT preparation — what actually moves a score, and how far it moves in the time you have.
- Tottenville High School on schools.nyc.gov — the DOE’s own page for this school.
Figures from NYC Open Data — School Quality Reports, Multi-Year Metrics, New York City Department of Education. Rebuilt 2026-09-15. Method and caveats are set out on the index page.
Take the next step
Tell us the score you have and the one you need.
Write the target school or the number you are aiming at in the box below. We start with a diagnostic, so the plan is built on the distance you actually have to cover, not on a package.